Despite being set in 1995, She Kills Monsters at Theatrical Tendencies, directed by Christopher Orth, taps into the feelings of today with poignant heart and precision. While we might spend our days overwhelmed by the news or exhausted from battling for some sense of normalcy and kindness in the world, TT gives audiences the chance to take a break. Here, we escape to New Landia and cheer on a tremendously talented ensemble cast who are the exact heroes we need: strong, magical, and full of heart.
But, as lead character Tilly (Ariana Manghera) would quickly remind us at sword-point: “This is not therapy.” Instead, this is a romp and roll of the polyhedral dice, as we hurtle along a fast-paced gamification of a play that feels less like a traditional 2-Act show and more like we’re in a living and breathing Dungeons and Dragons simulation. Written by Qui Nguyen, SKM breaks up the pace with narration (Sharon Sohner) that feels straight out of your favorite, worn-out VHS copy of Practical Magic.
Orth fully embraces this vibe right away with a prologue that expertly introduces us to the era by skipping modern projections; instead, enchanting us with bedsheet shadow puppetry work. We’re at our best friend’s house for a sleepover, Orth signals. Let the night begin.
Nguyen’s story is one not just about D&D but about sisterhood, friendship, and fitting in. Tilly’s sister Agnes (Summer Kleppek) did not spend enough time getting to know her sister in real life. Still, guided through Tilly’s campaign by Dungeon Master Chuck (Kilian Collins), Agnes dives headfirst into Tilly’s world, finding a place where monsters roam, bedeviled in cheerleader uniforms and shapeshifting from gelatinous blobs to obtuse boyfriends.
Agnes sees the world through Tilly’s eyes as she quests through New Landia. Kleppek’s Agnes serves as a proxy for the status quo. Today, she might be listening to Taylor Swift while sipping from her Stanley cup. Kleppek plays this well; it can’t be easy to perform the comedic foil among literal elves, wizards, and fairies who leap, dance, and cast hilarity around you. Kleppek finds the balance.
As Tilly and her D&D avatar, Tillius, Maghera is striking and aspirational. She imbues the level 20 Paladin with a self-assured swagger, while also accessing profound emotional depths in the play’s heavier moments.
Blending intentionally into the background but ever-present and, occasionally, the absolute star, is Collins—guiding us noobs and sages alike through the story. He’s animated, committed, and a little erratic; somehow all without stealing focus. The party of heroes is equally enchanting as they are endearing. They appear to us in an homage to the cult-classic Freaks and Geeks as they come out to battle to the sounds of Joan Jett’s “Bad Reputation.”
Anna-Christina Alcozer shines as a magical, element-wielding dark elf, Kaliope. Alexa Farrell takes on double duty as costume designer and Lillith, blending a perfect mix of sensual sexuality with fierce warrior-queen toughness. Rounding out the party, reluctant Orcus is charmingly brought to life by William Salinas, who grounds what could be a horny trope in a thoughtful and fully-realized character, even as he’s decked out in a nod to Kinky Boots. No spoilers, but we see other sides of all these characters that touchingly remind us: inside every geek is a little freak.
Reality collides with fantasy while each ensemble member juggles multiple roles and many battles. Orth makes excellent use of these talented performers. Though swordplay and weapon work abound, it’s perhaps the fistcuffs between Dungeon Master Chuck and Agnes’ boyfriend Miles (Nathan Broege) that best highlights the actors and fight choreographer, Jason Peregoy’s skill at making a stage fight look as real as it gets. In such an intimate space, realistic fight choreography is a remarkable achievement. The ensemble works overtime to differentiate each battle, and Peregoy’s fights show much of how Agnes grows in her understanding of the game and of her sister.
As the lights go down on New Landia, we return to our own battles—but maybe less empty-handed than when we arrived, armed now with the play’s triumphant spirit of these perfectly played, geeky freaks.





Rating & Rundown
Our Recommendation: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — A Must-See
What: She Kills Monsters at Theatrical Tendencies
Where: Inspiration Studios 1500 S 73rd St, West Allis, WI 53214
When: October 10, 11, 17, 18 at 7:30 P.M. and October 12, 19 at 2 P.M.
Purchase tickets for $25 at the door or at Theatrical Tendencies Website
What Else?
Inspiration Studios is a small space, and while most of the seats are great, we recommend getting there early to secure a spot away from the door. The wings can be a little loud.
Bring your Venmo! The space serves as an art gallery, and Theatrical Tendencies Vice President, Carly Irland, has a table of D&D TT merch you’ll for sure want to purchase!
About Theatrical Tendencies: Theatrical Tendencies presents professional quality theatre that meets a rising demand in the LGBTQIA+ community for audiences to see their life experiences represented on stage. They offer diverse productions with contemporary and alternative lifestyle themes that explore complex and varied situations such as relationships, family, prejudice, and values. Learn more.

